Losing Schools and Jobs (Hour 3)

Transcript

Losing Schools and Jobs (Hour 3)

Daybreak w/ Brian and Jamie · Thu Apr 30, 2026

Kathryn Lake

You're listening to Civic Media.

You can tune into any of our live shows on any radio station across the state with the Civic Media app.

Find us in your phone's app store and listen anytime, anywhere.

Across the state of Wisconsin, Daybreak with Brian and Jamie is back.

806 right now.

Thank you so much for joining us this morning.

Hopefully you are having a great start to your Thursday.

If you're in Wisconsin Rapids listening on WFHR in Hayward listening on WBZH or in the Appleton in Oshkosh area listening on WISS.

We are glad that you decided to spend your morning with us.

My name is Jamie Martinson.

And good morning.

I'm Brian Noonan.

Glad you're here.

If you want to get involved in the program throughout the rest of the morning, 855-755-CIVIC.

855-752-4842.

People go, slow down on the number.

Remember, 7-5-CIVIC.

That's all you need.

That's fine.

Spell.

Or you can always just go to one of our social media platforms and messages there.

Watch us on YouTube, messages there.

You know.

Lots of options.

We're accessible to you.

too accessible to ask me, but that's just me and my isolationism.

I patterned myself after the administration.

I try to be an isolationist whenever possible.

All right, let's look at some headlines from the war that we're still in, the war of choice.

Brent crude oil prices, the global benchmark surged above $126 per barrel this morning after setting a new wartime high as the president lays the groundwork for an extended blockade of Iranian ports.

Iran's oil minister meanwhile urged Iranians to cut consumption.

Also in news from the Middle East, the strategic significance of the Strait of Hormuz is nothing new, as the Strait remains effectively shut today.

Iran's regime is seeking to display the country's centuries-long control over the crucial waterway in its celebrations of Persian Gulf Day.

Celebrated every year since 2004, this event marks Iran's victory over Portugal in 1622 when it expelled Portuguese troops from the island of Hormuz.

In the midst of all of

Kathryn Lake

this,

they still want to have a celebration.

I can respect that.

I can respect that.

Sure.

The country's history.

Hopefully they don't do anything drastic with the current people who are blocking.

Right.

That's it.

All right, so that's all the headlines from the war.

But that's never all the things you need to know.

It's a wake-up

call in more ways than one.

Time for some shit you need to know.

All right, proposed rule change could cut federal benefits for disabled adults.

That's the Trump administration.

That's what they're considering.

If approved, this rule would cut monthly federal benefits meant to support disabled adults and indigent, older people who live with family members.

ProPublica first reported on the proposed change on April 28th based on information from four federal officials, internal emails, and a federal regulatory listing.

The organization analyzed actuarial figures from the Social Security Administration and found that as many as 400,000

poor and disabled people and indigent older people could have their support cut or eliminated.

The supplemental security income program run by Social Security Administration provides an average monthly payment of $737 to about 7.4 million people with severe disabilities and to indigent older and I've said indigent now more than I've said it in the rest of your life.

Yes.

Indigent older people as of

as of early 2026, according to Congressional Research Service.

One factor Social Security considers when determining SSI eligibility is whether a person lives in, quote, a public assistance household.

For decades, Social Security narrowly defined a public assistance household as one where every person in the home had to receive some form of public assistance, if even one person in the home.

did not receive such benefits it would hurt the disabled person's chance of qualifying for SSI supplemental nutrition assistance programs or SNAP was not among the qualifying programs the proposed rule change would remove SNAP from the list and again require all household members to receive public assistance so if you if you have an older parent living with you who gets those benefits

This would erase their benefits.

And again, their whole financial care would be on you.

I did some rudimentary research on how this is going to affect Wisconsin.

And these are very rough numbers.

But right now in this state, more than 30,000 adults with intellectual and developmental abilities live with family members.

We're talking at home with parents, siblings, loved ones.

And here's the part that a lot of people don't realize.

About a quarter of those caregivers are over the age of 60.

So

Kathryn Lake

that

means if you have aging parents as you rightly pointed out 60 70s even older and they're still providing daily care for adult children with disabilities

This is something you're going to want to pay attention to.

And across the state, about 1.1 million Wisconsinites are actually caregivers in some form.

That's nearly one in four adults.

And on average, they're providing 26 hours of care every single week, often unpaid, helping take care of those family members through the assistance that they get because of the federal government.

But we didn't vote for this.

We certainly certainly did not a lot of people did not vote for this in fact, but Okay,

it's crazy

crazy numbers

again.

It's led to should we point out the irony that while Services like this proposed cuts to average Americans are coming.

There's no shortage of money for right an increase in defense spending right and tax breaks for

the wealthiest amongst

us.

We talked about that a few weeks ago on the show.

When the president released his budget for the upcoming year, it was the most unfriendly people budget that I think we've seen in this country in maybe ever.

but it was very defense friendly.

And here's the thing, I believe our military should have what they need to defend this

Kathryn Lake

country.

I

am not one of those people who has defund this and defund that.

I believe that our military, our police forces should all be funded in some capacity.

They should have what they need to do their jobs, but at the same time, I also believe people should have what they need to live and take care of themselves.

And both can be true.

Yes.

You can have both.

Yes, absolutely.

So we should try to do it.

What other S do we need to know, Jamie?

In other headlines this morning, it turns out we're coming closer to Wisconsin.

Open Records advocates have landed a major legal victory for transparency throughout the state.

In a decision that was released on Tuesday, a Dane County court sided with the Badger Project and its co-plaintiff, the Invisible Institute.

This is a Chicago-based journalism organization in their lawsuit that demanded that the state to

Department of Justice released the names and work history of every certified law enforcement officer in the state.

Judge Rhonda Lanford gave this ruling and Tom Kamnick, who is the lead attorney and founder of the Wisconsin Transparency Project, that's a law firm dedicated to enforcing the state's open records law, said, quote, this decision is a powerful victory for the right of the public to know who has been entrusted with a badge and a gun.

filed a lawsuit in 2023 when the state DOJ partially denied the request for the policing data.

The department cited safety and privacy concerns, especially for undercover officers.

The data requested would include an officer's name, birthday or birth year, zip code, and his or her work history.

In response to that denial, the Badger Project and Invisible Institute sued in 2024.

The plaintiffs argued that since undercover officers don't actually use their

true names, releasing them wouldn't put them in jeopardy.

The state DOJ's 2023 denial was unlawful, the court wrote in the opinion that was released on Tuesday.

Citing an earlier decision, the judge noted that law enforcement officers necessarily relinquish certain privacy and reputational rights by virtue of the amount of trust society places in them and must be subject to public scrutiny.

That's a mouthful this morning.

That is a mouthful.

Uh, yeah.

I, boy, I have a problem with, I have a problem with this because there are, there's a reason that some, I think police need oversight.

We'll say that right out of the

box.

I don't think police records need to be available to the public.

I think they should be available to agencies and law and, you know, the state to

conduct investigations to conduct oversight, all of that.

I don't think you and I need to have access to police officers information that is going to lead to nothing but trouble.

There's no reason unless I'm part of a lawsuit.

And again, the law firm would be able to get the information, the state will be able to get the information.

You and I don't need to do that.

No.

Everybody who's disgruntled because they got a speeding ticket every lunatic who has some gripe either real or imagined can get I just I don't like it and the The defense of undercover is really flimsy.

Kathryn Lake

Yes, because

even if you even if you get a fake undercover name and you have the rest of their information you Someone would be able to find out who that officer is

So that defense doesn't hold water for

me.

I thought it was interesting that as part of this ruling as you read through it and the courts make it clear that transparency for them is what still matters here.

I thought that it was interesting they point out that without that type of transparency

We can't track the misconduct.

We can't understand how officers move from one department to another.

And we can't have fully informed conversations about policing in our communities.

And I don't agree with that.

I don't think we need to be able to track misconduct.

I feel like that should be done at the hands of the government and the people in charge of those departments.

And journalists, I think journalists should be able to get to those records.

And as journalists, you can request that information.

Right.

That's a request and it's usually a fairly quick process

that

you go through for journalists.

But I don't really need to know why police are moving from one department to another.

I feel like sometimes that's done just like anybody else.

Maybe you need to move to a different department for your own health reasons or because maybe you don't want to be on the street anymore.

Maybe you want to do more of a desk job.

I don't feel like I need to know that.

I think at some point we have to trust our police forces.

Listen, I know a lot of people have questions about how police operations are run across the country.

But I think at some point you also have to step back and...

not community police, everything too.

Because I don't know if that gets us very far.

If we're constantly tracking what's happening in our police departments.

I feel like this is more of a, this feels like one of those public scanner type things to me, right?

Yeah.

Where

you can follow along and-

Easy, Gladys Kravitz.

Yeah.

We don't need to know.

But

I think

the information should be there for people who absolutely need it.

And I think, as you mentioned, journalists, certain organizations, certain departments, they should absolutely be able to get that information.

I don't know if all of us need to have it in our fingertips, though.

We do not need.

The public does not need certain information.

All right, but we need to know why gas prices are going up and up and up.

And finally, pardon me, and as you need to know,

Gas prices in southeast Wisconsin are expected to spike now through the first few days of May.

The main cause is a power outage at the BP Refinery in Whiting, Indiana, which is where the bears will be playing, Frank, a key supplier for eastern Wisconsin.

ongoing labor disputes and seasonal refinery maintenance mean there means there's less backup supply available.

Analysts say some stations may raise prices sharply while others will increase gradually over several days.

Now Wisconsin's average gas price is already up to about 393 per gallon rising quickly from last week and last year.

Southeast Wisconsin is going to be hit the hardest while western parts of the state are seeing lower prices due to a different supply source.

Prices could top $4 a gallon in some areas.

Global factors are also at play, including tensions in the Strait of Hormuz, affecting oil supplies.

Experts say the spike could last four weeks before prices stabilize.

So I took your advice, Jamie.

You said yesterday was supposed to be one of the highest days.

I went and filled up.

Stick or shock?

Yeah.

Again?

I'm like, how does it go up every day?

I'm starting to see photos from around Wisconsin.

There are some places at at least $4 a gallon.

Chances that it could actually be over that before, as you mentioned, we see our prices stabilize.

So, take care of those

wallets.

The old commercial used to say Wednesday is Prince Spaghetti Day, but should it be Spaghetti Day at a brewer's game?

Well, what's the weirdest thing you've taken into a gamer concert to eat or

Kathryn Lake

drink?

We'll get to that after this on Daybreak on the Civic Media Network.

Local news, community stories, and the conversations that matter most.

Now, more Daybreak with Brian and Jamie.

It's 8.22 right now.

We hope that you are having a great start to your Thursday.

Thank you so much for joining us on the Civic Media Network.

My name is Jamie Martinson.

And good morning.

I'm Brian Noonan.

I have been known in the past, mostly when I was young, to try to sneak certain things into...

various

Kathryn Lake

events,

whether it's a sporting event like a Brewer's game, for example, or a movie theater.

But some people take it to an extreme.

So what's the craziest thing you've ever brought in to a game or a concert?

8-5-5-7-5, Civic 8-5-5-7-5, 2-4-8-4-2.

This was this question was spurred by a Milwaukee area fan and his friends and conjure We had to double-check this was not Parker and his buddies last Saturday.

No I'm afraid it was not I'm ashamed to say I don't even know these people.

I think

you need to make friends.

I think I need to make these friends.

Yeah

So these are guys, they brought in, it was a little stunt.

Mitch Kreps is 32.

He's from St.

Francis.

He organized a full spaghetti dinner inside the stadium during the Brewers win over the Diamondbacks on the 28th, which was Tuesday.

That was Tuesday's game.

The group, and this is all legal, by the way, because the Brewers are one of the few places you can bring in your own snacks.

You're not at the mercy of their concession stands, which are top tier.

but they're a little pricey but yes.

So they brought in all the ingredients under the stadium's carrying policy in which fans can bring personalized size food items if they fit in a clear plastic bag.

So Krupp's and his five friends divided up the meal responsibilities.

One brought noodles, one brought garlic bread, somebody brought Parmesan cheese, meatball sauce, even paper plates.

It wasn't hot by the time they sat down.

But it is hilarious.

It's spaghetti.

It

doesn't need to be hot.

It's still delicious.

Yeah, I listen just for the just for the few moments of hilarity that will ensue.

I got to believe.

So somebody brought in a Cubs fan, I guess came to and fan and talked about bringing in a Chipotle bowl.

That's

Lame.

Lame.

That's what I would expect from a Cubs fan.

We're just going to do a chain restaurant, bro.

Bro, see if it's, let's go to Chipotle.

Get us a drink.

And I know all Cubs fans don't sound like inbred Southerners, but enough do.

Well, we'll defer to Frank on that later on, but we'll keep going.

Frank is seething right now.

See thing well crepes was right He said brewers fans could do it better and then and hence the spaghetti dinner

Wow.

Have you ever taken anything like that in?

No, I have not.

I am a rules follower, so I take my clear little bag with all of my little things in it, and it fits neatly, and I'm good to go.

Plus, I love the stadium food.

I'm sorry.

Spaghetti

sounds amazing,

but I love it.

But I get it.

I get it if you want a little competition with your counterparts in the Cubs.

Well, also, sometimes you're tailgating, and you don't have time to eat everything.

Now is it like a quart-sized Ziploc bag or can you bring the gallon-sized Ziploc bag?

I think you can bring the gallon size.

I'm pretty sure these are gallon sized.

I could fit like four brats in there.

Oh, you could fit it.

You could fit probably.

Yeah, a lot of stuff in a gallon size Ziploc bag.

There's a lot of spaghetti.

I've had leftover spaghetti that I put in a Ziploc bag.

You could fit a lot of spaghetti in a gallon size Ziploc.

No, they had the paper plates, so they didn't have to eat right out of the bags.

That's what I was concerned about.

Oh yeah, no, these guys sound like they had it together.

They're professionals.

All right, all right.

I just wanted to make sure nobody looked like they were eating out of a trough.

off in that 13 to two win because that could get a little messy.

But I mean, I think this is actually genius.

Now, Kreps is actually already known among his friends for some of these very creative stadium traditions, including drinking Ham's beer with a slice of lemon, something that has gained a lot of local popularity.

He

also

called, I guess, I don't know.

I've never heard of Ham's with the lemon.

I was going to say, people

actually drink Ham's.

That's what surprises me the most.

from the land of sky blue waters.

Of course I'm gonna drink it.

It's the beer refreshing.

He

also calls himself the president of a fan created hot dog club at the ballpark.

And despite all of this viral attention that he's gotten, he says that he doesn't see himself as any sort of influencer, joking that he's just someone that people enjoy watching.

I don't know, you got a hot dog club and you started Hams with Lemon.

I think that you are totally a brewer slash stadium influencer, no matter what you want to say about

yourself.

And dude, now we're talking about

you on the show for your spaghetti dinner.

All right, Parker, now you, your friend, the last couple of weeks, you've gone to a couple brewers games with your friends.

What are you, what are you going to do?

Thanksgiving dinner, you're going to bring a whole, all

the fixings.

We could bring all the fixings.

I did see a video recently of a guy who brought in a full rotisserie chicken.

Nice.

Oh, I

like that.

I like that idea.

That's

good.

Bring in the chicken, but then you gotta have somebody who's gonna bring some cornbread and some taters.

That's true.

Some macaroni and cheese if you want to go that route.

Oh, don't forget the plates or Jamie can't join you.

They were on a medieval times this meal.

I don't

want

anybody to look like they're eating out of a trough.

That's just

weird.

We would imagine the greasy fingers dipping back into the rotisserie chicken bag.

Pass me the bag of meat.

Oh, thank

you.

This

is great.

I think this is fantastic.

If for anybody who's wondering, Kreps says that this might not be their last themed meal.

They have some good ideas for the future.

They want to bring in some fried rice or maybe even a full party sub that they carry into the stadium.

Jamie, we could do charcuterie boards of each fancy.

Oh,

we

totally could.

That

would be so good.

We could do all of that.

Oh, that would be so

good.

We could definitely do a charcuterie board.

I love charcuterie.

What's your favorite part of a charcuterie board?

The dry white cheeses.

Oh, yeah.

Spicy yeah, like an Ozzy I go or some sort of those are my that's my favorite end of salami

I like trying to up myself on the cracker game too, right?

Cuz you can go out

you can get

the standard crackers.

That's

gotta have

good crackers really good crackers

I've learned a lot of charcuterie board tricks from my daughter.

She loves making the charcuterie boards So she I have I actually have a couple charcuterie.

Oh nice.

Oh, yes, because I am fancy They were both

They were both gifted to me, so.

That's good.

She's taking care of you.

She's taking care of you.

Yeah, sure.

All right, well, we need to be taking care of the schools, and we haven't.

We'll talk to Miranda Dunlap from Wisconsin Watch about what's happening to the districts whose referenda did not pass in the current election.

We'll get to all of that and more.

This is Daybreak on the Civic Media Network.

Now back to more of Daybreak with Brian and Jamie.

Good morning.

Thank you so much for joining us today on the Civic Media Network.

Hopefully you are having a great Thursday.

It's 8.35 right now.

My name is Jamie Martinson.

And good morning.

I'm Brian Noonan.

Over a billion dollars in referendums from 73 school districts were on the ballot earlier this month, voters approved 37 of the 63 operational referendums, which asked to raise money, of course, to fund the cost of running schools.

The 12 other proposals wanted capital revenue to cover construction costs, things like that.

Nine of which passed.

Wisconsin Watch did a thorough breakdown of the effects of the referendums on school districts.

Joining us to share some of those findings is Miranda Dunlop from Wisconsin Watch.

Miranda, thanks for being here today.

So prior to the election, a Marquette University Law School poll warned that voters were more worried about property taxes than school funding.

So was it still, though, a shock to see how many of the referendums failed?

I don't know if the number of referendum that failed was necessarily a shock.

I mean, the passage rate taken all together was pretty in line with previous years, if a little bit higher.

So I wouldn't say that it was a total shock.

I think the poll also helped warn us that people are becoming wary of

out of taxes so um no not really a shock.

Can you walk us through what happened because your reporting is centered on Fond du Lac and so can you kind of walk us through what happened in Fond du Lac and why voters rejected that referendum and then what happened immediately after that?

Um sure I you know fold this closure I'm not um

super well-versed in exactly what happened in Fond du Lac.

It was definitely a detail in the story, but I wasn't following it in the lead up to the election.

So probably not the best person to give a full breakdown of that, but they did have a $30 million referendum on the ballot and it did not pass.

There have been budget cuts in previous years ahead of this.

So this is kind of like solid wound a little bit.

you're looking at even more cuts moving forward because of that.

And the changes that have been made in the district in just the week since they found out that they're not getting that added revenue, it's moved pretty quickly.

They've already announced closing two schools, which is a big decision to make.

They're cutting dozens of staff and there's gonna probably be

program shut down, things like that.

So, you know, pretty quickly finding out after after voters rejected that, that there's going to be pretty direct impacts in the schools because of that.

Are those impacts being seen in the other districts who also did not have their referendum passed?

Absolutely.

I think the

main point that we're trying to draw here with this story is that this is a trend.

This is not just one district where a referendum didn't pass and now they're making changes and they're an outlier because of it.

This is happening everywhere.

All over the state, in the places in the two dozen districts where these referendum did not pass, all of them are opening up their budget books and saying,

Okay, where can we find the money to plug this gap basically?

So not alone in that.

As you mentioned, the layoffs, impossible school closures, programs being cut.

After these referendums don't pass is that, I mean, obviously schools have to make hard choices.

So that seems kind of typical.

But does this feel more like an accelerated situation this time with the schools?

Because it seems like they had plans pretty much set just in case at this point.

Yeah.

I mean, I don't think it's a stretch to say that things are becoming more and more.

consequential.

I mean, at this point, a lot of these school districts would say that they've been operating with tight end budgets for years now because they haven't seen a substantial increase in school funding that's keeping up with the the factors that they're taking on like inflation and declining enrollment and those sort of things.

So they these school districts would probably say that they're doing they've been doing more with less, which makes

these rejections hurt even more because they were relying on it more, if that makes sense.

So I think as far as the speed with which the changes have been made, I'm not super sure if this has happened in the past like this, but it does definitely feel like it's becoming more urgent.

Miranda Dunlaps, our guest, she's a journalist from WisconsinWatchWisconsinWatch.org.

I want to go back to something you were saying a couple minutes ago, Miranda, about trends.

Augusta County, you reported on, had a relatively small request, $750,000.

So when even a small need like that doesn't pass, what does that mean looking forward for not only taxpayer support, but then where

have there been discussions of where they can find this money?

If they can't get it from the people in their community for guessing not a huge increase per person with only $750,000 asked, what's the future hold for them?

Yeah, you know, they're definitely looking at where they can make cuts, where they can trim up their budget, lose staff, those sorts of things.

I think

the district superintendent was also someone who called on our lawmakers to, you know, change something and give them some reprieve, come through maybe with a little bit more money.

I think there's sort of like two things that school leaders are thinking about after voters tell them no is one is

Can we go back to them again with a different ask that they might be more willing to say yes to?

And the second is, can our lawmakers do something about this?

And for lack of a better term, bail us out of this.

Before we let you go, Miranda, there's been a lot of talk that if these referendas don't fail for some districts, we're going to have to move into something that Wisconsin has not seen before, and that's consolidation.

Has there been much talk or as you were talking to these districts, is that something that seems to be coming either immediately in some places or down the road for other districts?

Absolutely.

It's definitely a topic of conversation.

Three of the school districts that I spoke to and you know, not all of them called me back.

So that

Kathryn Lake

was

a good share Said that they were either one is planning on closing entirely Unless something changes, I believe that is the plan they canceled summer school and you know, they're done at the end of the year And the other two are thinking about how they can one is thinking about how they can merge with maybe a nearby school district and

have students take classes in those buildings or kind of just, you know, be absorbed by a nearby place and another is thinking, you know, if we don't, if we're not able to pass a bond in the next cycle or referendum, sorry, in the next cycle or is that something that we're going to have to talk about is closing entirely or merging?

Yeah.

Yes, absolutely.

It's a big topic.

Miranda, we appreciate your time this morning.

Miranda Dunlap.

She is a journalist over at Wisconsin Watch.

If you want to check out more of her work and all the great work they do over there, WisconsinWatch.org.

Again, thank you so much for your

Kathryn Lake

time, Miranda.

We appreciate

it.

I mean, Brian, I think this is an ongoing conversation that we're going to see here in the state of Wisconsin.

And we knew how touchy these subjects were going into this April 7th election.

But I'll be honest, I was actually shocked at how many actually passed the school

referendum.

That was a pretty big, pretty big ratio.

And as Miranda said, it's not too out of line.

I want to know if your district had a referendum, it didn't pass.

And if it didn't, especially if it didn't, if your kids go to school in a district that a referendum did not pass, or if you live there and it did not pass,

How is it going to be addressed in your community?

855-75 Civic 855-752-4842.

I mean, we've talked about this on the show, and I've been pretty public about my experience growing up.

And I know for a lot of folks in Wisconsin, seeing a school consolidate is somewhat new.

You know, growing up in South Dakota, I'll be honest, you have sometimes two, three, four school districts that consolidate into one because of the size towns that we're dealing with in South Dakota.

You don't have a lot of major population, right?

have a lot of small towns that are completely separate little entities of about 100 to 150 people, sometimes two to 300 people.

And those towns cannot afford to have their own school districts.

So they actually have to go out and find other school districts and other towns to partner with.

So in one case, you had the Plankington, Ethan, I'm trying to think, Emery, and Parkston School District.

There are four school districts combined into one on that.

particular instance.

I came from a school where there were three school districts combined into one.

And yes, travel is a problem.

You bus.

Uh, you

Kathryn Lake

have to

figure out what, what buildings to use.

You have to figure out what teachers are going to stay and where their, their skills are most used.

But for towns of 150 to under people, it's what made the most sense for South Dakota.

So this is not anything new for me.

No, and it's not new around me.

I see it mostly with high schools, where smaller communities will have their grade school, and then a number of communities will come together for one large high school.

Which makes sense, but then as you get into more rural areas, that

Kathryn Lake

it does

become like you're describing in South Dakota, where you have to bring some of those together.

And in parts of Wisconsin, that may be the only option, which is not...

There are bad points to it, but there's also some good points where you can bring together some of that money and you can create a better environment for the kids because now there's shared money that will get facilities.

It will get all kinds of stuff.

Linda is on the line.

She's in Eau Claire.

She wants to join us now at 855-75 Civic.

Good morning, Linda.

Hi.

The topic you're talking about here gets really frustrating.

For many of us who for years have been watching what's happening with the public school system.

Do you know that since the 90s when vouchers first came into being in Wisconsin, over four trillion dollars has been taken out of public schools?

No one is talking about this, the effect of vouchers, how they are killing public schools.

You're right

we don't we don't focus on it enough and vouchered the voucher system is the bane of public schools and It doesn't make sense to most people myself included, but thank you for the call into we appreciate it Yeah, we aren't talking about that and that is a staggering number

it

is a staggering number that that that much money that could be used and I have I'm the product of a private grade school in high school.

I'm not I'm not against private schools, but

My parents sacrificed a lot.

go to private school.

I

think it's gotten out of hand, and with the voucher schools, it's become a way of, again, kind of like what we've talked about this morning.

There's been a running theme with the Voting Rights Act of basically making sure that some people don't have the same rights as others.

That's what the voucher school program has eventually, effectively become.

I'm a product of public schools until I got to college, and then I ended up in private colleges for my continuing education, but I am very much a product of public schools.

I'm very proud of my education in public schools.

My daughter went to public schools and my parents and I taught in public

schools.

No beef on public schools, no

shade.

I think what's happening to our entire school system is a problem.

Private schools are a choice that you can make and usually it's for people who have

Have some more money or their kids get scholarships.

It is a sacrifice to go to a private school.

Public schools are

Kathryn Lake

for the people who don't have that luxury.

This is the Civic Media.

to Lake Michigan.

This is Wisconsin's Morning Conversation.

Hey,

Bray, with Brian and Jamie.

We hope that your morning is going well so far.

Thank you so much for joining us today on the Civic Media Network.

I am Jamie Martinson.

And

good morning.

I'm Brian Noonan.

Wisconsin's manufacturing sector lost about 86,000 jobs in 2025.

Is that something we should be worried about?

Is the number a little misleading?

Where did that job loss actually come from?

Ricardo Torres is a journalist for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and he was covering all of this.

We are happy to welcome him back.

Ricardo, thanks for being here.

We appreciate it as always.

Okay, so that's a pretty big number.

Is that number a little misleading or does that mean companies are just bailing or is the number coming from somewhere else?

Oh,

one big point of clarification.

It's 8600.

Not 8600.

Well, I like to add zeros.

Sorry, no,

you are

correct.

8600 big difference.

Yes.

Yes, slight difference.

And this was, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, their data has been coming out this last month.

There was a slight delay because of the government shutdown and accumulating and benchmarking that data to see if what has been reported turned out to be accurate.

And in Wisconsin, yes, manufacturing jobs contracted by 8,600.

One of the things that we thought that was very interesting.

We didn't have some big layoff We didn't have some big company shut down a factory close or things like that and just in talking to people in the industry a lot of this has come from people retiring and then those jobs not being filled or people switching jobs and They're not being enough workers to fill those jobs

So, Ricardo, how is this affecting some of our major employers throughout the state, like Milwaukee Tool and some of the others right now?

Milwaukee Tool has job openings.

There are jobs available at it, and they're having difficulties filling some of those positions.

And it's not a unique problem to manufacturers in the state.

What a lot of companies are doing is they're looking to robots.

They're looking to AI and other forms of automation to continue to get their products out there.

I was at Rockwell a few months ago.

And I was watching robots move pallets that are hundreds of pounds that normally a forklift driver would do.

And these robots are just kind of moving around the floor by themselves.

They have cameras, they have sensors.

They could pick up things, move it.

other places without there being real much risk of injury to other people.

But so that's kind of what manufacturers are doing.

I don't mean to

laugh.

I'm

watching your face, Brian.

So I know you have questions about this.

Well, no, no, I just I think the robot thing always worries me.

But to get back to the

not being able to fill the jobs.

Are the manufacturers making the choice to go more automated?

Because we know there are people who are looking for work.

Is it the type of jobs that are opening that just there are no qualified candidates?

Or is it one of those where it's in the long term for these manufacturers, it's more cost effective to go with automation rather than a human employee?

I think it's a mixed bag of several of those things.

We have job openings.

But we have a labor shortage.

We don't have enough workers in this state able to fill those jobs.

And we could fix that by having more people from out of state relocated to Wisconsin, obviously more from immigration and people coming into the country and coming to Wisconsin to help solve some of those issues.

And so out of necessity, companies are moving more towards robotics and automation.

But also, they're still dealing with this stigma of your grandfather's factory.

And it's not anymore.

It's not anymore.

But there's that stigma that lingers out there that it takes some more effort to break through to younger generations that these are careers worth going into.

Yeah, and I wanted to ask you about that.

We're talking with Ricardo Torres.

He's a reporter at the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

Jsonline.com if you want to check out some of his work.

That was my question.

Are younger workers just not interested in these types of manufacturing jobs?

Is it a skills gap?

Is that something that we could see helped by our technical schools training programs?

So yes, but also we're not having as many kids as we were 50, 60 years ago.

So even if you had, say, from a percentage standpoint, the same percentage of workers that in the past were going into these jobs, you're still ending up with a deficit of or having a surplus really of more job openings than there are.

people to fill them.

So there are trades that are going out there.

They're trying to be competitive with their wages, with their benefits to attract more more workers.

Sometimes it works.

Sometimes it doesn't.

It's it's kind of a mixture.

Ricardo, we only got about two minutes left and you're reporting you said that the decline that we saw in Wisconsin last year is not what didn't surprise economists.

But what does it mean going forward if

This trend continues.

So the biggest issue that we have in Wisconsin's economy is this labor shortage that we have companies that want to hire workers and are having trouble finding the right workers to fill them and having enough qualified applicants to fill them.

And this is some of that's persisted with the state for a while, and it's going to continue, at least in the short term.

That's probably the biggest thing that companies and economists worry about is how long is this labor shortage going to go on for?

All right.

Well, it is always a pleasure to talk to Ricardo Torres.

He is a journalist from the Milwaukee Journal Center.

You can read all Ricardo's fine work at jsonline.com.

Good to talk to you, buddy.

Thanks for being here.

We'll talk to you again soon.

Thanks for having me.

All right, there you go.

So

This is it convince people to move to Wisconsin.

I know people like we don't want any more people moving here Well, we there's jobs here.

You could come and get people

here to fill these vacancies

Whether it's teachers nurses people who want to work in factories people there's there's work Wisconsin the land of opportunity.

I'll work for the state tourism bureau.

We'll share our

cheese

with

you

There's another slogan.

We'll

share our cheese.

We'll share our cheese.

Oh, man.

Come to Wisconsin.

Make some bank.

All right.

Listen, we're done.

I'm out.

We're finished.

We're done talking to you.

But thanks for being here.

Thanks for being part of the program.

We will talk to you again tomorrow.

I'm Brian Noonan.

This is Daybreak.

I'm Jamie Markison.

This is Pacific Media

Kathryn Lake

Network.

The national news cycle never stops, but it can be hard to find news about your local community.

Civic Media is dedicated to providing quality local and state news coverage across Wisconsin.

With the Civic Media app, you can get notifications about local stories that matter to you and your community.

Find the free Civic Media app in your phone's app store and choose notifications from the menu to tell us what kind of news you want to hear about.

0:00