You hear it every election: "energy independence." It sounds simple. Drill more, import less, control our own destiny. But the more you look at it, the more complicated it gets.

The United States produces more oil than any country on Earth. We're also a net importer of crude — over six million barrels a day — because our refineries were built for a different kind of oil than we drill. We export what we produce and import what we need. And even at record production, when Iran choked off the Strait of Hormuz, gas prices jumped forty-five percent. Because oil is priced on a world market. Drilling more doesn't change that.

So what would actual energy independence look like? Not relying on a commodity whose price you can't control. It would mean running on energy sources that don't have a world price — because there's nothing to buy. Sunlight. Wind. A battery in your basement. The only energy you truly control is energy you don't have to import.

Learn More

The U.S. is the world's largest oil producer — and still a net importer. Production is roughly 13.8 million barrels per day, yet we import over 6.2 million bpd of crude because our refineries need a different type of oil than we drill. The "net petroleum exporter" label politicians use includes natural gas liquids and refined products — it's misleading about crude oil specifically. (EIA; Poynter/PolitiFact)

The refinery mismatch: U.S. shale produces light, sweet crude. About 70% of U.S. refinery capacity was built for heavy, sour crude from Canada, the Middle East, and Venezuela. Retooling costs $100M-$1B per facility. (American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers)

Record production didn't prevent the price spike. When Iran blocked the Strait of Hormuz in early 2026, crude jumped roughly 45% to $95-100/barrel — despite the U.S. being at record production. Resources for the Future noted: "There is no such thing as energy independence, particularly when it comes to oil." Energy economist Mark Finley of Rice University put it simply: "If something goes wrong anywhere, the price goes up everywhere." (Resources for the Future; FactCheck.org)

"You can't weaponize the sun." RFF board member Catherine Wolfram used this phrase to capture why renewable energy offers something fossil fuels never can: immunity from geopolitical disruption. Solar and wind have no fuel cost, so their price isn't affected by wars, pipeline shutdowns, or OPEC decisions. (RFF)

Wisconsin imports ALL its fossil fuels. The state has zero coal mines, zero oil fields, zero natural gas wells. Wisconsin spends roughly $14 billion per year on imported fossil fuels. Every dollar of renewable energy generated in Wisconsin is a dollar that stays in the state. (RENEW Wisconsin)

Related Civic Minute segments: Oil Is a Global Commodity (CM-23), Does Drilling More Lower Gas Prices? (CM-24), We Drill It, Export It, Import What We Need (CM-28), The Sun Doesn't Send a Bill (CM-30)