Supreme Court Showdown: Sotomayor's Stand and Posner's Legacy

Transcript

Supreme Court Showdown: Sotomayor's Stand and Posner's Legacy

Amicus: A Law Review · Fri Nov 13, 2026

This is Amicus, a lot of you, on the broadcast and podcast stations of Civic Media.

My name is Jim Santel, and once again, I am your host.

for the next 40 or so minutes talking as we always do our weekly review of all things related to the rule of law, the administration of justice, and often the operation of government as well.

Our agenda, our syllabus for this installment of Amicus Law Review follows that direction almost exactly as we have often done in the past.

We're going to be spending some time talking about the Supreme Court beginning with some things that a couple of the justices have said outside

of the formal trappings of the United States Supreme Court.

A couple of them have appeared in forums in and around Washington DC recently.

Some very interesting commentary about the work of the court and its operation.

Obviously, comments made in the wake of the recent election of the midterm voting.

and also comments about the past decisions of the Supreme Court in areas that we have talked a lot about on this broadcast.

Those commentaries coming from Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

And also Samuel Alito will tell you all about what they said.

And then we're also going to spend a considerable amount of time in this edition of Amicus talking about an appeals court judge, a federal appeals court judge.

You probably know him because although he was never on the Supreme Court, he is a lion.

He is an icon when it comes to American federal jurisprudence.

His name is Richard Posner.

And he was also a professor of mine for a number of years.

at the University of Chicago Law School.

His tenure there plainly long exceeded mine, which of course, three years in duration, but a remarkable career in the law at the University of Chicago as a professor, as an author, as a lecturer, and then also on the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.

The Court of Appeals, of course, in which we are sitting here in Wisconsin, along with Illinois and Indiana, Richard Posner.

at the age of 87 died this past week.

We just spent some time talking about the impact of his life, his career on the law, and discussing with some anecdotal support and also some general references to the goings on in his tenure, the importance of Richard Posner in our jurisprudence in ways to continue even long, long after his death.

this will continue to animate in many ways what we think about when it comes to the exercise of the jurisprudential views and expressions of judicial perspective in our lives.

We're going to spend time talking about Richard Posner and then returning to a court that he was never on.

although he was mentioned repeatedly as a possible candidate for the United States Supreme Court.

I'm going to talk about two recent oral arguments of the Supreme Court since we last got together here on Amicus.

I'm going to talk about a

an oral argument in a case called Nielsen versus Wantanabi that's going to have an impact upon the capacity of individuals in America, citizens and residents, to sue representatives, to sue officials, to sue agents of the federal government for alleged violations of the Constitution.

No small thing.

especially when it comes to some of the lawsuits and some of the concerns, some of the actions of federal officers on the streets of America in recent weeks and months.

We'll talk about whether or not the Supreme Court is going to overturn a case called Bivens, B-I-V-E-N-S, which would again dramatically change the capacity of individuals to go into court.

federal court in particular, to seek redress of grievances when it comes to addressing allegations of violations of the Constitution.

In that case, Nielsen versus Wantanabe, an oral argument of justice past Monday, and then on Tuesday, we'll talk about

A case, again, heard on Tuesday, a case involving the Department of Labor and Sun Valley Orchards.

And whether or not administrative law judges have the authority to enter judgments in cases, recognizing those judges, not Article III judges, not constitutionally affirmed and confirmed judges, but judges inside, in this case, the Department of Labor.

Do they have the capacity in their review of challenges

to the decisions of the Department of Labor, in this case, imposing fines and restrictions on a farm in New Jersey.

What is their responsibility?

What is the breadth of their authority?

The case is Department of Labor versus Sun Valley Orchards, the Supreme Court weighing in to some extent in the oral argument of this past Tuesday.

I'll do some reading of the tea leaves, as I often do on these broadcasts and podcasts, about what we saw in those two cases.

Nielsen.

and Sun Valley Orchards of Justice past week, and then some other commentary about other matters going on in the life and the livelihood of America when it comes to the administration of law in our nation.

But let's begin.

Let's begin with some significant commentary by two justices outside of the bench.

These are not comments.

These are not reviews.

This is not commentary made by them inside a particular case, but things said by them more and more frequently.

outside of the ambit of the Supreme Court.

Let's begin with Sonia Sotomayor.

She was appearing for a civics education talk at George Washington's Mount Vernon estate.

This was a part of the celebration at that location of the 250th anniversary of the United States of America and appropriately venued at the president's estate.

George Washington's estate there on the shores of the Potomac River.

Supreme Justice Sonia Sotomayor making headlines for what she said not only about civics but about the activities and actions of the court on which she sits.

Let's begin with the big headline.

She said she hopes that the court's decision with respect to former presidents and the broad criminal immunity conveyed to them by the United States Supreme Court.

That of course was the case of Trump

versus the United States might one day be overturned, rejected.

She says her colleagues have done some crazy things.

Those are her words, not mine, hoping once again that the time comes when the Supreme Court reverses that broad grant of criminal immunity granted to presidents with respect to some major areas of their work, even as their presidents.

of the United States of America.

The question, of course, under what circumstances might that happen, you recall well that Sonia Sotomayor and other members of the Supreme Court dissented bitterly.

a couple of terms ago when the Supreme Court for the first time in our history articulated principles articulated the standard that indeed there is one person above the law and that is the President of the United States of America an opinion authored by the Chief Justice saying the President's need necessarily to be strong cannot be diverted by cannot be subject to criminal prosecutions or the prospect of criminal prosecutions while they are in office.

Obviously a matter of great concern not only on this broadcast but for all Americans as we identify those circumstances under which individuals including the president should or should not be held accountable for his or one day her criminal involvement.

She was appearing once again for this civics matter.

She was also commenting about what she saw recently in those midterm elections.

She said we saw the outpouring of voters on Tuesday.

She made no specific mention of the results of that, but also commented about the significance of the turnout.

She said, I tell people all the time, there's no excuse for not voting.

There just isn't.

Apathy is not acceptable.

She was plainly supporting the great numbers of people who came out first time or times after they have not come out routinely.

And she also commented about the importance of civics in America, a commission of this broadcast and plainly of others, including the late Sandra Day O'Connor, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court.

The first woman ever to serve on the Supreme Court spent a lot of her time after her tenure on the Supreme Court.

promoting the notion of education among the population.

She served on a board of something called iCivics, an education group that she founded in an attempt to try to encourage a greater civics understanding among our American population, focusing on the state of democracy and the importance of things like voting.

The Associate Justice, Sonia Sotomayor, in that context said that it would, in her words, take some hard work.

for the country to get back on an even keel in the wake of, again, some of the crazy things, again, her words, not mine, that the Supreme Court has done recently.

She said, there have been some systemic changes in my court's jurisprudence in many areas of the law.

And she also went on to say, we'll settle down too.

Don't worry about this.

She said, I'm not quite certain when that will happen, but we will.

We'll settle down.

And a new order will be established.

that people will begin to understand.

Those, the comments of Sonia Sotomayor about where we are today and attempts that she is plainly going to pursue to reach that even keel after some hard work that she and others may do.

Again, commenting specifically about that king above the law articulation by the Supreme Court a couple of terms ago with which she did not agree then and which he does not agree today.

She been on to say

I just sent a lot in these cases, and indeed she does, as we've reported repeatedly on this broadcast.

She said, I'm hoping that the court will take back some of those things that it's done.

And then went on to say, I'm only joking.

And then paused.

And she said, well, maybe not.

And this, again, to a crowd about a week or so ago, she said, no seriously.

You know, I've spoken openly about this.

There's some opinions that I hope in my lifetime will get overturned.

The immunity case, returning to that, she said, immunity case is one of those.

Sonia Sotomayor, being very graphic about what the Supreme Court has done in many of these cases, specifically that immunity case granting presidents broad immunity, objecting to it once again and hoping that in some instance, in some time and place, the Supreme Court will have the opportunity to overturn what it has done.

Not any time soon, but hoping for that even keel to return to the jurisprudence of our highest court.

Another associate justice of the United States Supreme Court also appearing in public, not at the estate of our first president, George Washington, but at a hotel, which often is the case for major conventions of individuals and groups.

This a convention, a meeting of the Federalist Society annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner.

this happening just this past week and this is associate justice Sam Alito appearing obviously invited there to provide remarks at the time and commenting about again in the wake of what the american population has done to send to congress both a democratic majority and the house of representatives and also in the united states senate commenting about what the consequences of that might be

with respect to the very operation, the livelihood of the Supreme Court.

We have commented in the past in many ways continue to do so about the importance of a legislative oversight with respect to many, many entities of the

federal government, and that includes the Supreme Court.

We know that the legislature can in fact change the number of justices on the Supreme Court.

That can be done legislatively.

We know that Supreme Court justices have appeared in front of committees of the Congress.

Most recently, Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett there to talk about budget issues and specifically talking about the need for increased funding, provide security for justices at a time when they, across the board,

are getting and are being on the receiving end of threats by individuals in the American population.

Something, of course, needs routinely to be condemned and stopped as an assault on our judiciary.

They also, of course, members of Congress have a budget authority, and that was plainly what grabbed the attention of Supreme Court Justice Sam Alito when he was appearing at the Federalist Society meeting just this past week.

He said this.

Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities.

Now that may be something of a hyperbole.

You like to think that the Congress would not simply turn off the lights and restrict completely any funding for the Supreme Court.

But he is right as a practical matter in saying that it is the Congress who start bills with respect to finances and a budget every year in the House of Representatives.

That's where hearings are conducted.

That's where again, on the Senate side, again, hearings are conducted about where monies, your monies, your federal monies will be allocated, including to the courts of America.

Federal courts do not have a separate budget line, a way of getting money from you and me.

They are a part of the overall allocations made by the Congress.

And so when you pay your taxes, you're also supporting what the federal courts do, the district courts, the circuit courts, and yes, the Supreme Court as well.

San Milito very much aware of that.

And again, perhaps in something of an exaggeration saying, well, you know, they could shut us down completely.

probably would not do that, but they certainly have the capacity to make decisions that will affect the operation of the Supreme Court by virtue of the things that the House and the Senate will do when it comes to budgeting.

He went on to say, in addition to his comment about the capacity, literally, constitutionally true, of stopping everything if they want to defund our activities, he said, and there are many, many, many, three mennings.

other things that they can do, or at least try to do.

And that, of course, is important as well.

Budgets are statements of policy, as we know, and they're not without controversy and can also, of course, often prompt lawsuits with respect to the allocations of monies and the executions of budgets by President, Sam Alito, saying, so it is important to preserve the independence of the judiciary, talking about the power

of the Congress to implement budgets that would have an impact upon the Supreme Court, but also affirming what we all recognize as important, which is the independence of the United States Supreme Court, even with that.

We talk about all of that, of course, because it is the mission and purpose of this broadcast, Amicus Law Review.

to review things going on in our courts.

And in particular, when it comes to the Supreme Court and other courts, that is our mission here on Amicus a Law Review, broadcast stations, podcast stations of civic media.

Sam Alito, again, talking this past week, who group gathered for the Federalist Society, he went on to say, again, that the power of the legislature is there and that he

continues to believe that the judiciary needs to be, as we all believe it needs to be, independent of powers and authorities and the imposition of decision-making authorities of legislature, even as the legislatures can restrict.

the jurisdiction, the kinds of things that the Supreme Court can decide, they can do that.

What they should do is dictate the ways in which they make decisions and the decisions themselves, even though we can, under our First Amendment, be critical of those things and frankly be opposed to them, as Sonia Sotomayor has indicated as well.

the legislature cannot and should not tell the Supreme Court how to decide cases as controversial as many of those decisions can be in the views of many Americans.

So we have these major decisions coming out of the Supreme Court, which are also then the subject of comments by our justices as they leave the bench and speak not just in Washington, but in other places around our nation about the work of the Supreme Court.

Let us go from the Supreme Court to the United States Court of Appeals, as you know well.

As we discussed routinely on this broadcast, the United States circuit courts, there are about 14 of them altogether when you add on the federal circuit and some specialized courts, but 14 different circuit courts.

These are the courts of jurisdiction immediately below the United States Supreme Court.

Although they are populated by panels of judges at these levels around the country, typically decisions made by them by three judge panels.

And we talk about that a lot on this broadcast.

Sometimes there are all cart panels that are convened if the cases, if the subject matters are sufficient importance.

Those are called en banc en.

BANC proceedings, but most often there are three judge panels who review what the lower courts, the district courts do.

There are about 93 of those district courts all around the country.

And those of course are courts that eventually feed into the appeals courts, ultimately feeding into the United States Supreme Court.

Well, one of the judges who appeared not only

on the Seventh Circuit, but had an iconic legendary term of service on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals was a fellow named Richard A. Posner.

He was an intellect of the highest orders, had a relentless work ethic, and amazing candor with respect to his work, his time on the bench, defying in many ways a specific

description of him as being conservative, although he is often described that way.

Richard A. Posner died on Tuesday this past week in Chicago, which has been his home for a long period of time.

He was 87 years old.

He served from 1981 to 2017 on the United States Court of Appeals with the Seventh Circuit.

It is a fair representation.

that he wrote literally thousands, thousands of judicial opinions, and believe it or not, more than 50, 50 books on a variety of topics.

This is a man who is greatly interested in the courts, in the ways in which we decide cases and the jurisprudence of judges, and the interaction between courts and the ways in which the decisions of judges affect and implement not only the law, but affect the people in our nation.

Huge numbers of very scholarly articles, many of them routinely quoted by other judges and justices, essays on the practice and conduct of the law, book reviews, did an awful lot of blogging in recent years.

He was, as many journalists have indicated, a one-man think tank.

And among other things, he was the most cited legal scholar in the second half of the 20th century.

Let me say that again.

The most cited legal scholar in the second half of the 20th century, that's according to a very reliable 2000 study of these kinds of things.

He wrote judicial opinions with great frequency and his

Opinions were also the subject of review, discussion, often objection.

more often than perhaps any other judge, maybe even more than other justices of the Supreme Court.

Many people noted that his tenure astonishing in nature and the lead that he provided not only with respect to defining the law and giving us a sense of where it was and should be is at the top of the list in terms of the kinds of work that he did.

Admirers of Justice Judge Posner are many and they are diverse in politics.

There are many people who said there was no real competition for anyone in his jurisprudence.

He was a superb writer.

He has this very conversational style and a very strong command of tone.

He had self-confidence in what he was doing.

But he did it in a diplomatic way, and it did it in a way that attracted an awful lot of attention.

A former dean of the University of Chicago Law School, his name was Saul Levmore, said, Posner was the greatest and most skilled judge in American history.

He said, part of his influence was his willingness to think aloud and imprint about what law may be trying to accomplish and how it might go about that.

Posner himself described his approach to judging as being very pragmatic.

His critics called it lawless.

He said this, he said, I pay very little attention to legal rules, statutes, and constitutional provisions.

Wow, what a thing to say, right?

He said in a 2017 interview, a case is just a dispute.

The first thing you do is ask yourself, forget about the law.

What is a sensible resolution of this dispute?

What a refreshing way of viewing all those kinds of things.

And inside that very pragmatic approach to this, he was also one of the leading figures on something began very early on in his academic career at the University of Chicago as a leader in what's called law and economics.

He was looking always to social utility when it came to deciding cases.

doing things in resolution of those cases, more than abstract moral value.

those are even legal, developing a reputation for applying practical economic principles.

What is most sensible in terms of money and economics in resolving cases?

We're doing this as a part of our review of the great life and legacy of Richard Posner here on Amicus Law Review, broadcast stations of civic media, because it's helpful in understanding what judges around the country can and should be doing and the great impact of this particular judge.

when it comes to the jurisprudence of our nation.

When Judge Posner was just 33 years old, he published a thing called Economic Analysis of Law and it helped establish him in this field.

That was way back in 1972.

Again, many, many books in the areas of antitrust and law and literature.

He wrote a book called Sex and Reason.

He wrote a book about the impeachment of Bill Clinton, the 2000 election recount, and even the September 11 attacks on national security.

All of that, all of that, as the work that Richard Posner was doing during the course of his time, not only on the bench, but also as an academic.

I mentioned that because Richard Posner was also a professor of mine.

When I was a student at the University of Chicago Law School, he taught me all about economics and what I did, one of the books that I still have is his economic analysis of law and also his book on antitrust.

And I remember very well his instruction on antitrust, a great interest of his when it comes to economics and review of economic decisions.

And again, a professor of mine during the time of his tenure, which continued long after I was there and long after he was on the bench of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

Ronald Reagan appointed him to that position in 1981.

He was 42 years old.

And as I indicated before, there was frequent talk of his being nominated to the United States Supreme Court.

He certainly had free market principles in mind when he wrote many of these books, and again, defied in many ways a clear characterization as being a liberal, as being a conservative, even though he applied some principles that many thought were conservative in nature.

He had, as I indicate, no patience for formalism and legal reasoning.

and again rejected a lot of focus when it comes to legal writing.

He was not a fan, not a fan of originalism and that of course the interpretation of law and even the Constitution that seeks to a divine and then to apply the original public meeting of the text of the Constitution.

He was more interested again in the practical consequence of those decisions.

His

career again spanned many, many years.

And even though he may have drifted somewhat to the left during the course of his term, issuing opinions on everything from voter ID laws and abortion and same-sex marriage, workplace discrimination, all of those things were also a part of his overall view.

that wherever your particular analysis takes you, whether it's conservative or liberal, that is appropriate.

His overall methodology pretty much remained unchanged during the course of his term.

Let me give you a few examples of that.

In 2013, he wrote an opinion blocking a Wisconsin law that restricted abortions.

In other words, he was in favor of

the Wisconsin position, which permitted abortions.

Anticipating the 2016 Supreme Court decision, he wrote this.

He said, courts must balance the supposed health benefits of abortion restrictions against the burdens that they impose on access to abortion.

He acknowledged that he sometimes needed to change his mind.

In 2007, long before all that was going on, he wrote a majority opinion upholding

an Indiana voter ID law.

And in 2013, he wrote a book called Reflections on Judges.

He said, I was wrong.

I was wrong back in 2007.

He said, I plead guilty to having written the majority opinion that was affirmed by the Supreme Court.

Well, I held this requirement that prospective voters in Indiana prove identity with a photo ID.

And he indicated that that type of law now widely regarded as a means of voter suppression.

that rather than a matter of fraud prevention, he said he regrets that particular opinion.

Getting back to Wisconsin, again, a large intersection between him and the State of Wisconsin, elaborated in a 2014 dissent in a case on Wisconsin's voter ID requirement, writing that those laws are a mere fig leaf for efforts to disenfranchise voters likely to vote for the political party that does not control the state government.

When he followed what he said were the Supreme Court's commands and he did so, he understood that as an appellate court judge, he had to do what the Supreme Court told him to do.

He sometimes did so plainly, very begrudgingly and with a certain amount of limited protest.

In 2012, he wrote a majority opinion that blocked an Illinois law.

that banned carrying guns in public.

Let me say that again.

He wrote a majority opinion that blocked an Illinois law that banned carrying guns in public, saying the result was required by what we've often discussed here on Amicus Law Review is that 2008 Supreme Court decision, Heller.

Heller, of course, the case written by the Supreme Court majority by Antonin Scalia.

was also a professor at the University of Chicago, contemporaneous for a time with Richard Posner, 2008 Supreme Court decision Heller saying that there's an individual constitutional right for law-abiding citizens to keep guns in their homes for the purpose of self-defense.

Well, Posner went along with that begrudgingly and he reviewed the empirical literature about all of that.

and said the practical consequences about the crimes and bans on carrying guns in public, he found it somewhat inconclusive, unlike the Supreme Court itself.

Anyway, anyway, Posner wrote, the Supreme Court made clear in Heller that it wasn't going to make the right to bear arms dependent on casualty counts.

That is a strong piece of language, a piece of writing by any judge of an appeals court, basically saying the Supreme Court not attentive to the impact of what it did in Heller and in other cases.

That's the kind of thing that Richard Posner would do, again, defying a clear understanding of who he was and how he engaged in his work, finding in his pragmatism a way to set his own course and determine

the results that again he viewed as important to the life and livelihood of people, pragmatically living in the community.

All of that, all of that a part of the legacy.

We mourn his passing.

I remember well his wonderful instruction, a brilliant instructor, a brilliant academic, had the opportunity long after I graduated to attend some of his programs at the University of Chicago.

And also I should mention,

had the opportunity to appear in front of him when he was on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals, when I was representing the government in a number of criminal and civil cases.

He was often on the panel of those cases, ultimately authoring opinions in matters in which I was defending the United States of America and the positions of the U.S.

Department of Justice.

Richard Posner

intersecting my life and the lives of many, many people in America, not just lawyers, not just law clerks, not just other judges, not just other justices on the Supreme Court, but all of us.

That is the legacy of Richard Posner, 87, when he died in Chicago at his home this past week.

Let us return now to the Supreme Court once again and talk more about a couple of opinions that are going to be issued by the Supreme Court in this coming term probably.

in May, maybe June, maybe even July of this term.

We talked previously about one of the major cases that it took up on election day that is St.

Mary Catholic Parish versus Roy, a major separation of church and state opinion, a free exercise opinion that appears from the tea leaves there that the Supreme Court is going to decide.

in favor of the St.

Mary Catholic parish, the Archdiocese in that case, and find that the imposition of and the requirement by the state of Colorado of its law there that prohibits discrimination in the admission practices of anyone who accepts any entity that accepts

public funds, including the Archdiocese, that the Catholic Church has to be permitted to follow its own views.

In this case, same-sex marriage, that their decision to discriminate based upon the admissions of youngsters who might be the products of and inside families of same-sex partners.

that that cannot be used to prohibit them from getting public monies.

Sounds as if the Catholic Church is going to win in that case over the state of Colorado that was arguing that its discrimination statute required that it not give monies to the Catholic Church as long as it had pursued.

that discriminatory practice, sounds as if the Catholic Church is going to win in that case, as we discussed previously.

Two other cases also on the docket of oral arguments in recent times, since we have gotten together in our last edition of Amicus a Law Review.

One of them on Monday, November 9th, Nielsen versus Watanabe.

Nielsen versus Watanabe, a major case involving whether or not, whether or not Americans, residents, citizens will be able to sue agents.

including agents, federal officers, including ICE agents for allegedly unconstitutional things that they might do on the streets of America and generally in America.

Now, this particular case involves an individual named Kakai Watanabe, W-A-T-A-N-A-B-E.

It's a $3 million lawsuit against a federal prison nurse.

The plaintiff in that case says that he should have been hospitalized or a senior specialist

after being attacked during a gang-related fight in prison in Honolulu in 2021.

Instead, he was given some over-the-counter pain medication and sent on his way.

An x-ray is taken months later, showed that he had a fractured bone and bone chips, and they had migrated to some soft tissue areas.

He did not receive any further treatment before he released in 2024.

and remains in tremendous pain today.

The lawsuit alleges that because of the actions, in this case inactions, of a federal officer, namely this federal prison nurse, he should be able to sue, seeking damages.

He wants $3 million as a result of all of that.

And here on Amicus, a lot of you broadcast stations of civic media, podcast stations of civic media, I'm going to tell you next exactly

how this gets to the Supreme Court and what the issue is before the United States Supreme Court as argued on Monday, November 9th.

What they did, of course, was Supreme Court takes up this case and determines, going to determine whether or not Mr. Watanabe can in fact go ahead with his lawsuit against this particular federal agent.

The lawsuit presents the opportunity of the court to overrule a case.

involving a case called Bivens.

And Bivens is a case that allows people to sue federal officers for monetary damages.

The full name of the case is Bivens versus six unknown name agents.

It's a controversial 1971 decision that does indeed give people the capacity

presumably, including Mr. Watanabe, the ability to sue in federal court for alleged constitutional violations.

So if Bivens is in place, presumably, Mr. Watanabe, with respect to some requirements that he's got to meet under Bivens, could go ahead with his lawsuit.

The Supreme Court taking up this particular case to determine in part.

whether Bivens should continue to be a part of our jurisprudence in America.

If, in fact, Bivens is eliminated by the Supreme Court in this case, there'll be literally no way to sue in federal court whenever a federal agent, yes, a federal prison nurse, but also, for example, someone who's on the streets, an ICE agent, a Border Patrol agent, a federal officer in any of federal agencies generally, whenever a federal officer violates the Constitution,

or allegedly does just that.

That's why this case is so very important.

In recent years, the courts have sought to limit the ability to sue federal employees, including barring lawsuits and cases that are different in some meaningful way, as they've sometimes said, from the details that are spelled out, the requirements of Bivens.

And there are only in only two other cases in which the Supreme Court

has allowed these kinds of constitutional claims to go forward.

The appeals court said that Mr. Watanabe passed the test in Bibbins and ruled that it's identical to a Supreme Court decision in 1980 in which the Supreme Court said that a federal prison staff member had violated the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment when they failed to respond to a prisoner's

attack.

Lots going on there.

Nielsen versus Watanabe.

And it appears that there is some interest by the Supreme Court in reviewing.

and determining whether Bivens still is viable.

If they use the Watanabe case to overturn Bivens, any lawsuit against a federal agent, including those that we've talked about a lot on this broadcast, that America is focused on a lot, any of those lawsuits presumably would be barred under the Constitution.

You could not pursue them with respect to federal agents, even if you are alleging

viable constitutional claims.

Huge consequences of this case argued this past Monday.

Also significant consequences of another case argued on Tuesday.

And that's Department of Labor versus Sun Valley Orchards.

This particular case involves, again, a major issue with respect to who makes decisions about claims.

In this case, the Department of Labor, an agency of the federal government, it is inside the executive branch determining that a farm in New

Jersey had violated certain labor laws and principles and guidelines with respect to its treatment of day laborers and farm laborers, not only the conditions of their employment, their payment, but also access to food and other matters, all kinds of things alleged by the Department of Labor in its investigative authority against Sun Valley Orchards.

Now, Sun Valley Orchards contests all that says we've never done it.

And the case goes to an administrative

law judge inside the Department of Labor, inside the agency itself, that at least in another portion of that agency is making the very claims against Sun Valley Orchards.

Sun Valley comes forward and says, wait a minute, we should not be subject to an administrative decision by an administrative law judge employed by the very agency that's making these charges against us.

We should be able to get directly to an Article III constitutional law judge.

That's the issue before the Supreme Court argued on Tuesday, this past Tuesday, seemed to be some interest by the Supreme Court, perhaps in overturning this mechanism that exists throughout our federal government, where administrative law judges inside many agencies, not just the Department of Labor, make preliminary decisions deciding on claims made by the agencies significantly.

Those are always subject to review.

by a federal district court judge, ultimately by circuit court judges.

But the question is whether or not these administrative law judges on the first blush, the first take, the first cut on any of these claims have the ability to enter judgments in this case, fines against a farm for doing these kinds of things with respect to its day laborers and farm workers under its jurisdiction.

A major issue with respect to the capacity.

of administrative law judges, which again are a central portion of the way in which our federal government does work.

Are they acting constitutionally, even with the appellate rights that follow, or should they not be doing these kinds of reviews at all?

Major case involving the future, we know as well that the Supreme Court is also in the weeks ahead.

going to be addressing other issues related to asylum and immigration, to guns, and also to voting in America.

We'll talk about those cases and future additions of amicus, a law review.

For now, I thank you again for tuning in and being a part of our exploration of the rule of law, the pursuit of justice, and the operation of government here on the broadcast stations of civic media.